Fishing Bills Lake

Newaygo County, Michigan · DNR Survey 2023

Scout's Fishing Notes

Bills Lake produces some of the fastest-growing walleye in southwest Michigan, running nearly two inches above state average across all age classes. The 2023 survey found walleye from 12-25 inches with 93% of legal size, mostly from the successful 2016-2018 fall fingerling stockings. At 204 acres and 80 feet deep, Bills Lake offers excellent walleye habitat with good dissolved oxygen to 37 feet and optimal water temperatures in the 64-72°F range through summer stratification. The lake's marl bottom with sand areas and littoral shoals provides diverse structure. Northern pike present a different story entirely - they're severely stunted with a mean growth index of -4.5, running more than 3 inches below state average. Of 143 pike captured, 96% were under 24 inches, indicating serious overabundance. Special regulations now allow harvest of 5 pike daily with no minimum size limit (except only one over 24 inches). The panfish fishery is outstanding, dominated by black crappie running 8-15 inches with most in the 10-11 inch range. Bluegill reach impressive sizes with 40% over 8 inches and two fish hitting 10+ inches - rare for southwest Michigan and qualifying for the Master Angler Program. The lake stratifies strongly in summer with surface temps near 79°F dropping to 45°F at 80 feet, but maintains good oxygen levels through the optimal walleye zone. Clear water with 13.5-foot Secchi depth makes this a sight-fishing lake in the shallows. The DNR access on the northwest shore provides good boat launching for the 20-space parking area.

Top PredatorWalleye
Top PanfishBlack Crappie
Overall QualityExcellent walleye fishery with fast growth and good size structure. Outstanding panfish with quality black crappie and large bluegill.

Species Survey Data

DNR survey 2023 · Biologist: Addie Myers · Report #0427

Species Count Size Range Growth % Legal
Northern Pike 143 8.1-30.2" -4.5 well below average 4%
Walleye 104 12.1-25.7" +2 above average 93%
Black Crappie 76 8.0-14.9" 100%
Rock Bass 67 4.0-10.9" 85%
Bluegill 52 3.0-10.9" 79%
Largemouth Bass 51 8.0-17.9" 27%
Yellow Bullhead 14 10.0-13.9" 100%
Yellow Perch 11 5.0-7.9" 18%
Brown Bullhead 6 10.0-13.9"
Hybrid Sunfish 6 6.0-8.9" 100%
White Sucker 6 10.0-19.9"
Smallmouth Bass 1 10.0-10.9" 0%
Pumpkinseed 1 7.0-7.9" 100%
Common Carp 1 32.0-32.9"
Warmouth 1 6.0-6.9" 100%

Water Quality

13.5 ftWater Clarity (Secchi)
37 ftGood O₂ Depth
78.9°FSurface Temp
45°FBottom Temp

DNR Fish Stocking

Yellow Perch: 3,315 totalWalleye: 2,926 total
DateSpeciesStrainNumberAvg Length
11/6/2025 Walleye Muskegon 1,324 4.45"
10/25/2023 Yellow Perch 1,000 6"
10/3/2023 Walleye Muskegon 802 6.48"
10/17/2022 Yellow Perch 915 6"
10/20/2021 Yellow Perch 1,400 6"
10/5/2021 Walleye Muskegon 800 5.83"

Source: Michigan DNR Fish Stocking Database

Ice Fishing

Bills Lake's shallow profile means it likely freezes early and solidly in winter. Always check ice thickness before venturing out, but conditions should generally support ice fishing when Newaygo County lakes are freezing up.

DNR Management Direction

Continue biennial fall fingerling walleye stocking at 4 fish per acre. Encourage northern pike harvest through liberalized regulations. Promote natural shoreline restoration among riparian landowners.

Fishing Tournaments & Competitions

Check for upcoming registered bass, walleye, and muskellunge tournaments on Bills Lake.

Michigan Fishing Resources

Frequently Asked Questions

What fish are in Bills Lake?

Bills Lake has historically been known for northern pike and panfish. However, multiple anglers report fishing has declined significantly over the past 3-5 years. The clear water and shallow profile still support warm-water species, but don't expect the action that the lake once produced.

DNR Fishery Report · Data: Michigan DNR · ← Back to Bills Lake Guide