Fishing Tomahawk Creek Flooding

Presque Isle County, Michigan · DNR Survey 2004

Scout's Fishing Notes

Tomahawk Creek Flooding offers a diverse warmwater fishery in a shallow, vegetated 574-acre impoundment created in 1964. The lake doesn't thermally stratify, staying 73-74°F throughout the 11-foot water column with good dissolved oxygen to the bottom. Bluegill dominate the catch at 51% but grow slowly (0.9 inches below state average), with only 2% reaching 8+ inches compared to 8% in the 1980s. Black Crappie established since the 1980s and now comprise 6% of the catch, likely competing with other panfish. Largemouth Bass fishing attracts two registered tournaments annually despite slow growth 1.3 inches below average - 27% are legal size (14+ inches) with fish up to 20 inches caught. Northern Pike provide the bulk of predator biomass at 45% by weight but show extremely poor growth, averaging 3 inches smaller than statewide norms across all ages. Only 13% of pike reach the old 24-inch minimum, leading to liberal harvest regulations allowing any size to thin the stunted population. The flooding's sand and muck bottom supports prominent aquatic vegetation and extensive flooded timber, particularly on the south end - habitat uncommon in natural glacial lakes nearby. Winter and spring fish kills are common due to the shallow nature. Bullheads declined dramatically from 37% of the 1983 catch to just 1% in 2004, reducing competition for game fish. Rock Bass dropped from 20% to 2% of the catch between surveys. Most panfish compensate for slow growth by living long - up to age 10 for several species. The lake provides excellent shore fishing access around the entire DNR-owned shoreline plus a quality boat launch near the popular campground.

Top PredatorNorthern Pike and Largemouth Bass are equally common predators
Top PanfishBluegill
Overall QualityDiverse warmwater fishery with abundant panfish and predators, though all species show slow growth due to shallow, vegetated conditions.

Species Survey Data

DNR survey 2004 · Biologist: Tim A. Cwalinski · Report #0349

Species Count Size Range Growth % Legal
Bluegill 432 1-9" -0.9 below average
Largemouth Bass 111 2-20" -1.3 below average 27%
Pumpkinseed 107 2-9" -0.8 below average
Northern Pike 99 10-29" -3.1 well below average 13%
Black Crappie 52 4-13" -1.4 below average
Rock Bass 17 1-9" -0.5 below average
Bullhead 9 11-14"
Yellow Perch 8 5-8"
Common Shiner 2

Water Quality

9 ftWater Clarity (Secchi)
11 ftGood O₂ Depth
74°FSurface Temp
73°FBottom Temp
less than 100 mg/LAlkalinity

Stocking History

YearSpeciesNumberStage
1967 Golden Shiner 2,000 adult
1967 Largemouth Bass 110 adult
1967 Tiger Muskellunge 50,000 spring fingerling

Ice Fishing

Tomahawk Creek Flooding is shallow and freezes early and reliably each winter. Ice fishing for northern pike is popular here, and the light pressure means you'll likely have plenty of room to spread out. Always check current ice conditions, as floodings with creek inflow can have variable ice near moving water.

DNR Management Direction

Continue current liberal Northern Pike regulations to control stunted fish. Dam renovation recommended over removal due to demonstrated fishery value and high angler usage. Next survey needed in 10-15 years.

Fishing Tournaments & Competitions

Check for upcoming registered bass, walleye, and muskellunge tournaments on Tomahawk Creek Flooding.

Michigan Fishing Resources

Frequently Asked Questions

What fish are in Tomahawk Creek Flooding?

Northern pike, bluegill, largemouth bass, and smallmouth bass are the main catches. Pike are especially abundant in the shallow water, and bluegill fishing can be excellent — anglers report catching dozens of keeper-size gills in short sessions. The flooded timber and stick-ups create ideal warmwater fish habitat.

Can you ice fish on Tomahawk Creek Flooding?

Yes. The flooding is shallow and freezes reliably each winter. Ice anglers target northern pike primarily, and the shallow depth means you don't need to drill deep. It's a solid low-key ice fishing spot with far less pressure than the more popular northeast Michigan lakes.

DNR Fishery Report · Data: Michigan DNR · ← Back to Tomahawk Creek Flooding Guide